To add something new I'd say Tales of Abyss, Persona 4, or even the Mario & Luigi (yup ) series are some of my favorites. But I'm also a huge fan of Monster Hunter, Dragon Age, the Souls series, and the Mass Effect series. Currently going through Baldur's Gate EE and am enjoying it.
Dragon Age, without a doubt, because of all the moral choices, and also the romance options. I also really like Elder Scrolls, and have since Morrowind, and Final Fantasy since playing III in the nineties.